| Title | Artist | Year | Pressings |
|---|
| Indiana / Darktown Strutters' Ball | Original Dixieland Jazz Band | 1917 | 16 |
| Cavalleria Rusticana—Siciliana | Enrico Caruso | 1911 | 15 |
| Il Trovatore - Miserère | Enrico Caruso | 1910 | 14 |
| The Missouri Waltz / Little Alabama Coon | Louise, Ferera And Greenus | 1918 | 14 |
| Tosca - E Lucevan Le Stelle | Enrico Caruso | 1912 | 13 |
| Roamin' In The Gloamin' | Harry Lauder | 1912 | 13 |
| Hawaiian Waltz Medley / Kilima Waltz | Pale K. Lua | 1915 | 13 |
| Caprice Viennois | Fritz Kreisler | 1911 | 12 |
| The Herd Girl's Dream / Happy Days | Neapolitan Trio | 1912 | 12 |
| Humoreske (Op. 101, No. 7) / Berceuse From "Jocelyn" | Venetian Trio | 1913 | 12 |
| Paraphrase On "Die Lorelei" / The Herd Girl's Dream | Prince's Orchestra | 1913 | 12 |
| Élégie—Mélodie | Enrico Caruso | 1914 | 12 |
| Casey's Description Of His Fight / Casey Taking The Census | Michael Casey (2) | 1916 | 12 |
| Levinsky At The Wedding | Julian Rose | 1917 | 12 |
| National Emblem / Washington Grays | Prince's Band | 1911 | 11 |
| Cohen On The Telephone / Happy Tho' Married | Joe Hayman (2) | 1914 | 11 |
| There's A Long, Long Trail / There's A Little Lane Without A Turning On The Way To Home Sweet Home | Herbert Stuart | 1915 | 11 |
| O Sole Mio | Enrico Caruso | 1916 | 11 |
| Martha - M'appari = Like A Dream | Enrico Caruso | 1917 | 11 |
| Silver Threads Among The Gold / Nelly Was A Lady | Frank Coombs | 1910 | 10 |